Preferability Letters: A 15 Year Review

Financial statements are based on certain assumptions – known as accounting principles – that can have a large impact on presentation and comparability. For instance, one company might count inventory using the first-in-first-out (FIFO) method, while another in its industry uses last-in-first-out (LIFO). This contrast in accounting policies can lead to significant differences in the two companies’ financial statements.

When publicly traded companies (registered with the SEC) make a voluntary change in on of these accounting principles, they are generally required to obtain a “preferability letter” from their independent auditors. In the letter, the auditor states that the change in principle is in accordance with Generally Accepted Accounting Principles; essentially, that the new policy is preferable to the old one. The letter typically includes its own description of the change in accounting principle as well.

Since 2000, the number of preferability letters filed in a given year has fluctuated from a high of 108 in 2000 to a low of 57 in 2007. As can be seen in the chart below, before 2009 preferability letters were more likely to be filed in interim (quarterly) financial statements. In the past five years, however, a small majority of preferability letters now appear in annual filings.

CAP YtoY

Source: www.AuditAnalytics.com 508.476.7007

(N.B. The dates in the tables above and below are based on period end dates. E.g., a filing issued on 3/15/14 for the period end 12/31/13 would be included in the 2013 count. We estimate the 2014 number to rise to roughly 80 or 90 letters by the time all companies issue their annual filings. )

Over the last fifteen years the most common reasons for filing preferability letters have been: 1) Goodwill Impairment Measurement Date; 2) Inventory Valuation; 3) Expense Recognition; 4) Classification; and 5) Benefits Program.

As one can see in the chart below, letters relating to the impairment measurement date began appearing in 2003 and have exploded in number, accounting for over 40% of letters filed in four of the last six years. This trend prompted the SEC to make a statement at the AICPA Conference on Current SEC and PCAOB Developments in December, advising companies to file preferability letters for impairment measurement date only if the change in principle is material.

Preferability Letters by Issue Type

Source: www.AuditAnalytics.com 508.476.7007

The second most commonly cited reason for preferability letters has been changes related to Inventory Valuation. Interestingly, a large number of companies have been abandoning the LIFO method in favor of FIFO or Average Cost accounting methods. As seen in the table below, 178 companies moved away from the LIFO method, and 149 switched to FIFO.

CAP InvPreferability letters are an important indicator for corporate stakeholders. Companies can use them to determine whether or not they are using a “best practice” accounting principle. Investors and regulators can use them to determine if there is comparability between companies within industries. And all stakeholders can use them to determine trends in order to make better decisions.